ESC

Search NCEA

Find research, scholars, events, and media

Grid reliabilityMark MillsNuclearRenewable costs
Research
42results

Ask a question

Get an AI-powered answer grounded in NCEA research

Costs of renewable mandatesGrid reliability
Op-Eds

It's a Wonderful Fuel

NCEA quote graphic on the benefits of natural gas and oil
No items found.

George Green had reached the end of his rope. Humanity just didn't get that its large and growing appetite for energy was killing the planet.

As Earth Day approached, his mood took a dark turn. Poised at the rail of the bridge stretching across the river that flowed through Bedford Falls, he mused how much better the world would be if there were no fossil fuels . . . and no George Green.

It was then he saw the man struggling in the swirling current below. He tore off his jacket, leaped into the frigid water, and pulled the drowning man to shore.

After they dried off, the man thanked George and introduced himself.

"My name is Drake," he said. "I'm an angel who was sent here to save you from your despair. If I succeed, I'll earn my wings."

"Save me?" George scoffed. "It's the earth that needs saving from fossil fuels."

Drake looked skyward and after a brief and seemingly one-sided conversation announced, "Well, I see you're going to be a tough case, so I've just cleared it with the folks upstairs. I'm going to grant your wish. Fossil fuels have never been discovered."

"Yeah, right," George said searching the pockets of his jacket. "You must have bumped your head. Let me get my smart phone, and we'll Uber into town."

"Your phone isn't there," Drake told George. "Mobile devices were never invented. You see, without fossil fuels, there was no way to produce the materials that go into your phone or to power it and its network reliably. No tablets or televisions either, I'm afraid."

Unconvinced, George responded, "Hmmm, it must have dropped into the river. Looks like we'll have to walk. Hey, does this bridge seem a bit creaky to you?"

"It does. This bridge is made of wood. The one you jumped off to rescue me was made of iron and steel. Making those metals requires fossil fuels and metallurgical coal. Without them, it wasn't possible to run the large mills needed to forge enough iron and steel for things like bridges . . . or cars or airplanes or skyscrapers, for that matter. Remember your high school buddy, Abe Darby? Well, he's the town blacksmith."

"Huh? Abe owns a brew pub. Look, I really have to get back. I promised my wife I'd help her plan our summer vacation tonight. We're going to take the kids whale-watching and then camping in the forest."

"But George, there are no whales to watch anymore," Drake replied. "Because there was no kerosene to light the lamps and no coal to fuel the dynamos that powered Thomas Edison's light bulbs, hunters long ago killed off the whales for their oil."

"Are you kidding me?" groaned George. "Next thing you'll be telling me we can't go camping."

"Sure, you can go camping. Just not in the woods. America's forests are a thing of the past.

Deprived of fossil fuels, people kept using the next best thing to heat their homes and power their industry-wood-and today most of that's imported."

"Impossible," George protested, though lacking his earlier conviction.

"The truth is, George, nowadays when politicians aren't ranting about the evils of 'Big Wood,' they're scolding Americans for their addiction to logs, claiming it just enriches the OTEC cartel."

"OTEC?"

"The Organization of Timber Exporting Countries."* Taking in his unfamiliar surroundings, a confused George felt his defiance flag. Then it hit him. "What is that stench?" he gagged.

"Oh, that's the tons of horse dung being, ah, deposited in town every day. After all, with fossil fuels unavailable, there was no way to build cars in commercial quantities or to fuel them, even with batteries or ethanol. So America never progressed beyond using horses to get around. Henry Ford invested a bundle trying to mass produce buggies on an assembly line, but without an adequate source of electricity, he could never make a go of it. He wound up raising horses for a living."

"Horses?"

"Yes. Mustangs." Drake added, "Anyway, as bad as the stink and the insects and the diseases are, the indoor air pollution created when people burn the stuff in their homes is even worse. But in time, you'll grow used to it."

As the horrible reality of the situation washed over George, the angel said to him, "You've been given a great gift. To see what the world would be like without fossil fuels."

Frantic, George turned on Drake, gripping him by his lapels. "Where's my wife?" he gasped. "Where's Mary? Is she still the town librarian?"

Drake hesitated, then answered, "I'm sorry, George, there is no town library. The great philanthropist Andrew Carnegie never made a fortune in the steel industry because there never was a steel industry to speak of. So he never donated the funds needed to build the library where your wife would have worked. She's home churning butter."

"You see," the angel continued, "hydrocarbon energy has been of tremendous benefit to mankind, helping to fuel the largest flourishing of human health and welfare in all of history. I think you appreciate now that affordable, plentiful, dependable energy is the not the problem for what ails the world, it's a big part of the solution."

An enlightened George nodded his head. "Please, Drake, I want to go back-no-I want to go forward to my wife and kids and modern way of life."

"Very well, George, I'll send you forward again. And this Earth Day, be sure to spare a thought for the energy pioneers who made modern life possible and to the roughnecks, miners, frackers, oil refiners, IT specialists, nuclear engineers, grid operators, solar-panel and wind-turbine manufacturers, and countless others who every day deliver the energy services that make your lives, well, wonderful."

Oh yes, and Drake finally won his wings.

*A version of this article originally appeared on RealClearEnergy.

More from the blog

Unlocking U.S. nuclear growth and waste management graphic
Commentary

Solving the Nuclear Waste "Problem"

Nuclear is the new darling of the energy sector. Popular support for adding nuclear energy capacity is near an all-time high. Sentiments toward radioactive waste, however, remain uneasy.

Brett Rampal · May 12, 2026 · 2 min read

U.S. Energy Security Index NCEA cover graphic
News

Leading Energy Indicators: Introducing the U.S. Energy Security Index

Energy security rarely dominates the news - until something breaks. A supply disruption. A geopolitical conflict. A cyberattack. A price shock.

· Mar 12, 2026 · 3 min read

Energy sanctions and U.S. global power presentation graphic
Commentary

Energy Sanctions and American Power: How Long Can the Leverage Last?

Not long ago, the United States was an oil supplicant - managing OPEC relationships carefully and constrained by import dependence.

Matthew McManus · Feb 26, 2026 · 2 min read

NCEA quote graphic debunking fossil fuel subsidy claims
Commentary

The $7 Trillion Number That Doesn't Exist

"Global fossil fuel subsidies hit $7 trillion." The IMF publishes it. The UN Secretary-General cites it from podiums. Climate organizations build campaigns around it.

Paul H. Tice · Dec 17, 2025 · 2 min read

NCEA quote graphic on utility-scale battery storage limitations
Commentary

The Grid Doesn't Charge Like a Phone

Picture a battery. A phone that runs out. A laptop that needs plugging in. The battery depletes, you refill it, life goes on.

· Dec 03, 2025 · 2 min read

Rising electricity bill graphic showing increasing costs
Commentary

Why Your Electric Bill Keeps Rising-And What the Usual Explanations Miss

For years, I've watched the debate over rising retail electric rates drift further from the underlying realities of how our power system works.

Jonathan Lesser, PhD · Nov 19, 2025 · 2 min read

NCEA quote graphic on renewable energy decommissioning costs
Commentary

Taxpayers on the Hook? The Coming Renewable Decommissioning Debt

When an oil well runs dry, or a nuclear plant reaches the end of its life, or a coal mine closes, there are rules for what comes next.

Curtis Schube · Oct 28, 2025 · 2 min read

NCEA quote graphic on Britain's net zero climate policies
Op-Eds

What President Trump Needs to Say About Britain's Economy-Destroying Net Zero Climate Policies

This week, President Trump is making his second state visit to Britain, a country that is Ground Zero of Net Zero.

· Sep 18, 2025 · 2 min read

NCEA quote graphic on energy education at U.S. universities
Commentary

Energy Education: Reality Check, Part 2

In Part 1 of our Energy Education survey, we found that the nation's top 50 universities overwhelmingly frame energy courses through the lens of climate change.

Mark P. Mills · Sep 03, 2025 · 1 min read

NCEA quote graphic on building large nuclear reactors in America
Commentary

Why We're Not Building Large Nuclear Reactors (and How to Start Again)

For the first time in a generation, the stars have aligned for a nuclear energy comeback. Public support is rising. Bipartisan enthusiasm is real.

Paul H. Tice · Aug 12, 2025 · 2 min read

NCEA quote graphic on EIA capacity data and gigawatts
Commentary

Gigawatts Aren't All Created Equal: Why the EIA's Capacity Data Misleads Policymakers

The United States is in the midst of a historic shift in how it produces electricity, spurred by tax credits, state mandates, and sweeping federal legislation like the "One Big Beautiful Bill Act." More than 1,100...

Jonathan Lesser, PhD · Jul 24, 2025 · 2 min read

NCEA quote graphic on energy education research findings
Commentary

Is Energy Education Grounded in Reality? New Research Suggests Otherwise

What students are taught matters. This is especially true for energy-an input fundamental to every activity, product, or service in society.

Mark P. Mills · Jul 09, 2025 · 1 min read

Social cost of carbon analysis graphic
Commentary

The Social Cost of Carbon: A High-Stakes, Flawed Metric

For over a decade, the so-called "social cost of carbon" (SCC) has become a central justification for wide-ranging U.S. climate and energy policies.

Jonathan Lesser, PhD · Apr 23, 2025 · 3 min read

Container ship at sea representing global maritime shipping
Commentary

Is Global Shipping the Hidden Weak Link in the Energy Transition?

In today's globalized economy, nearly everything we consume-electronics, cars, food, and even the raw materials that power the so-called green revolution-travels by sea.

G. Allen Brooks · Apr 09, 2025 · 3 min read

Power lines and electrical infrastructure at sunset
Commentary

Electrification Without Electricity-The Infrastructure Challenge

As America pushes toward an electrified future, demand for electricity is skyrocketing. From electric vehicles to heat pumps replacing gas-fired systems, the shift to electricity touches every corner of our lives.

Jonathan Lesser, PhD · Jan 23, 2025 · 2 min read

LNG tanker ship transporting liquefied natural gas
Commentary

America's LNG Future

As our planet becomes more electrified and industrialized, demand for energy of all kinds increases. One fuel where America has an advantage is natural gas.

· Oct 23, 2024 · 3 min read

SEC building exterior representing climate disclosure regulations
Op-Eds

SEC's Climate Disclosure Rules: A Threat to Economic Growth and Energy Security

In March 2024, the SEC adopted climate disclosure rules requiring U.S. corporations to report their carbon footprint and climate-related risks.

Paul H. Tice · Sep 11, 2024 · 3 min read

Electric vehicle charging at a home charging station
Commentary

What would an all-EV future look like?

Installing EV chargers requires significant upgrades. A dedicated home charger costs about $400, but most homes need a new service panel, raising individual costs to $1,750, and collectively over $1 million per neighborhood.

Jonathan Lesser, PhD · Aug 07, 2024 · 5 min read