ESC

Search NCEA

Find research, scholars, events, and media

Grid reliabilityMark MillsNuclearRenewable costs
Research
42results

Ask a question

Get an AI-powered answer grounded in NCEA research

Costs of renewable mandatesGrid reliability
Research

The Consensus Trap: How Manufactured Agreement Corrupts Policy

We describe a pattern common to three of the most consequential public policy failures of the past two decades—the 2008 financial crisis, the COVID-19 pandemic management, and the campaign for rapid decarbonization.
No items found.

This working paper, published by the Hoover Institution and co-authored by Hoover Institution Edward Teller Senior Fellow and NCEA advisor Steven E. Koonin, Hoover Institution Senior Fellow Scott W. Atlas, and NCEA advisor Terrence Keeley, examines a common pattern behind three of the most consequential policy failures of the past two decades: the 2008 financial crisis, the management of the COVID-19 pandemic, and the campaign for rapid decarbonization.

The study challenges the assumption that broad institutional agreement reflects settled evidence. The authors argue that in each case, powerful institutions and leaders aligned to manufacture a consensus the evidence did not support. They call this shared pathology “the consensus trap.”

Read the full paper at the Hoover Institution

Key findings include:

  • Each failure followed the same four-stage course: a consensus was asserted, credible dissent was suppressed, the policy failed, and no one was held accountable
  • The underlying mechanism was strikingly similar across all three cases: quick acceptance of flawed predictive models, aggressive discrediting of credible challenges, and amplification through the media and political leaders
  • The costs of these failures fell regressively, landing hardest on those least able to bear them
  • The consensus trap is likely to recur wherever complex data and high policy stakes meet, though institutional and societal reforms can make it less likely
  • A 2025 revision of the Federal Judicial Center’s Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence ties “widespread acceptance” to the highest level of scientific certainty, a link that could embed the confusion between manufactured and earned consensus in the federal courts

The paper concludes that genuine scientific consensus must be earned through open, critical debate of the evidence, not declared by institutions, and that recognizing the consensus trap is essential to keeping it out of future policy and the courts.

Read the full paper at the Hoover Institution

‍

More from the blog

Undersea operations are vital to contemporary American strategies for power projection, sea control or denial, and for naval war against rivals.
Research

AI below the waterline

Undersea operations are vital to contemporary American strategies for power projection, sea control or denial, and for naval war against rivals.

David G. Victor, PhD · Sep 22, 2026 · 40 min read

China is often held up as proof that a major economy can rapidly ditch fossil fuels while leading the clean-energy revolution.
Commentary

Two-Headed Dragon: How China Does Fossil Fuels and Renewables

China is often held up as proof that a major economy can rapidly ditch fossil fuels while leading the clean-energy revolution.

National Center for Energy Analytics · Jun 30, 2026 · 4 min read

Data centers are often blamed for rising electricity bills. But the evidence tells a more complicated, and more useful, story.
Commentary

The Data Center Blame Game: What's Actually Driving Your Electric Bill

Data centers are often blamed for rising electricity bills. But the evidence tells a more complicated, and more useful, story.

National Center for Energy Analytics · Aug 12, 2026 · 4 min read

The United Arab Emirates' decision to leave OPEC was a major blow to the organization; but its most important consequences may come later.
Commentary

What the UAE's OPEC Exit Means for Oil Markets

The United Arab Emirates' decision to leave OPEC was a major blow to the organization; but its most important consequences may come later.

National Center for Energy Analytics · Jun 28, 2026 · 5 min read

When oil and gas prices rise, consumers understandably look to government for relief. But history offers a warning
Commentary

When Energy Prices Spike, Resist the Crisis-Driven Fix

When oil and gas prices rise, consumers understandably look to government for relief. But history offers a warning

National Center for Energy Analytics · Jul 27, 2026 · 6 min read

Commentary

Coal Isn't Disappearing. Energy Policy Should Deal With That Reality.

For decades, Western policymakers have treated coal as a fuel on the way out. But global energy markets are telling a different story.

National Center for Energy Analytics · Jul 31, 2026 · 4 min read

Commentary

Direct Air Capture: A Lot of Energy for Very Little Climate Impact

Direct air capture is often presented as a technological safety net for climate policy

National Center for Energy Analytics · Jun 30, 2026 · 5 min read

Trading floor screens showing stocks falling and oil prices moving, with the Nasdaq and Dow tickers in red
Op-Eds

It's the Economy, Stupid — Again

"It's the economy, stupid." It’s election season and the ghosts of Clinton, Carville, Penn, and Schoen are back — or their playbook for electoral advantage, anyway.

· Sep 29, 2026 · 5 min

Commentary

The $4 Trillion Problem With a Battery-Powered Grid

Batteries are often presented as the missing piece of a wind- and solar-powered electric grid.

· Jul 30, 2026 · 5 min read

A long, brightly lit aisle between rows of server racks in a data center
News

Building the Next Generation of Energy Research

Why NCEA is building a custom AI agent and dynamic tools such as the Index of Leading Energy Indicators and NCEA-EMIT.

· Sep 24, 2026 · 9 min

Commentary

America's Electric Grid: A Century-Old System Meets a 21st-Century Surge

NCEA's report by Jonathan Lesser and Patrick McCormick finds America's aging electric grid badly unprepared for a sudden surge in demand.

National Center for Energy Analytics · Aug 17, 2026 · 4 min read

Commentary

The Wind Energy Reality Check Nobody Wants to Have

Jonathan Lesser and Portia Roberts test whether decades of promises about cheaper, cleaner, more secure wind power have actually held up.

National Center for Energy Analytics · Aug 17, 2026 · 3 min read

Commentary

America's Nuclear Ambition Has a Workforce Problem

Bipartisan support and data center demand put nuclear back on the agenda. The workforce needed to quadruple U.S. capacity by 2050 does not exist.

National Center for Energy Analytics · Aug 17, 2026 · 3 min read

For years, the world's most-cited energy forecast told a clean story: oil demand was about to peak, and the transition was on track
Commentary

The World's Top Energy Forecaster Just Quietly Admitted It Got Oil Wrong

For years, the world's most-cited energy forecast told a clean story: oil demand was about to peak, and the transition was on track

National Center for Energy Analytics · Jan 30, 2026 · 3 min

Unlocking U.S. nuclear growth and waste management graphic
Commentary

Solving the Nuclear Waste "Problem"

Public support for nuclear is near record highs, but unease about radioactive waste remains the objection that has stalled expansion for 50 years.

Brett Rampal · May 12, 2026 · 2 min read

NCEA quote graphic on the benefits of natural gas and oil
Commentary

It's a Wonderful Fuel

George Green had reached the end of his rope. Humanity just didn't get that its large and growing appetite for energy was killing the planet.

· Apr 22, 2026 · 4 min read

U.S. Energy Security Index NCEA cover graphic
Commentary

Leading Energy Indicators: Introducing the U.S. Energy Security Index

Energy security rarely dominates the news - until something breaks. A supply disruption. A geopolitical conflict. A cyberattack. A price shock.

· Mar 12, 2026 · 3 min read

Energy sanctions and U.S. global power presentation graphic
Commentary

Energy Sanctions and American Power: How Long Can the Leverage Last?

Not long ago, the United States was an oil supplicant - managing OPEC relationships carefully and constrained by import dependence.

Matthew McManus · Feb 26, 2026 · 2 min read

NCEA quote graphic debunking fossil fuel subsidy claims
Commentary

The $7 Trillion Number That Doesn't Exist

The IMF's $7 trillion fossil fuel subsidy figure is cited worldwide. Most of that sum is not a subsidy in any meaningful sense.

Paul H. Tice · Dec 17, 2025 · 2 min read

NCEA quote graphic on utility-scale battery storage limitations
Commentary

The Grid Doesn't Charge Like a Phone

Picture a battery. A phone that runs out. A laptop that needs plugging in. The battery depletes, you refill it, life goes on.

· Dec 03, 2025 · 2 min read

Rising electricity bill graphic showing increasing costs
Commentary

Why Your Electric Bill Keeps Rising-And What the Usual Explanations Miss

For years, I've watched the debate over rising retail electric rates drift further from the underlying realities of how our power system works.

Jonathan Lesser, PhD · Nov 19, 2025 · 2 min read

NCEA quote graphic on renewable energy decommissioning costs
Commentary

Taxpayers on the Hook? The Coming Renewable Decommissioning Debt

When an oil well runs dry, or a nuclear plant reaches the end of its life, or a coal mine closes, there are rules for what comes next.

Curtis Schube · Oct 28, 2025 · 2 min read

NCEA quote graphic on Britain's net zero climate policies
Commentary

What President Trump Needs to Say About Britain's Economy-Destroying Net Zero Climate Policies

This week, President Trump is making his second state visit to Britain, a country that is Ground Zero of Net Zero.

· Sep 18, 2025 · 2 min read

NCEA quote graphic on energy education at U.S. universities
Commentary

Energy Education: Reality Check, Part 2

In Part 1 of our Energy Education survey, we found that the nation's top 50 universities overwhelmingly frame energy courses through the lens of climate change.

Mark P. Mills · Sep 03, 2025 · 1 min read

NCEA quote graphic on building large nuclear reactors in America
Commentary

Why We're Not Building Large Nuclear Reactors (and How to Start Again)

For the first time in a generation, the stars have aligned for a nuclear energy comeback. Public support is rising. Bipartisan enthusiasm is real.

Paul H. Tice · Aug 12, 2025 · 2 min read

NCEA quote graphic on EIA capacity data and gigawatts
Commentary

Gigawatts Aren't All Created Equal: Why the EIA's Capacity Data Misleads Policymakers

Headlines credit wind and solar with 80% of new capacity, but EIA capacity data measures something different from electricity actually delivered.

Jonathan Lesser, PhD · Jul 24, 2025 · 2 min read

NCEA quote graphic on energy education research findings
Commentary

Is Energy Education Grounded in Reality? New Research Suggests Otherwise

What students are taught matters. This is especially true for energy-an input fundamental to every activity, product, or service in society.

Mark P. Mills · Jul 09, 2025 · 1 min read

Social cost of carbon analysis graphic
Commentary

The Social Cost of Carbon: A High-Stakes, Flawed Metric

For over a decade, the so-called "social cost of carbon" (SCC) has become a central justification for wide-ranging U.S. climate and energy policies.

Jonathan Lesser, PhD · Apr 23, 2025 · 3 min read

Container ship at sea representing global maritime shipping
Commentary

Is Global Shipping the Hidden Weak Link in the Energy Transition?

Maritime shipping moves 80% of world trade, including the minerals behind the energy transition, and may be the bottleneck nobody planned for.

G. Allen Brooks · Apr 09, 2025 · 3 min read

Power lines and electrical infrastructure at sunset
Commentary

Electrification Without Electricity-The Infrastructure Challenge

Demand for electricity is climbing fast as EVs and heat pumps spread, but the infrastructure needed to deliver that power is not keeping pace.

Jonathan Lesser, PhD · Jan 23, 2025 · 2 min read

LNG tanker ship transporting liquefied natural gas
Commentary

America's LNG Future

As our planet becomes more electrified and industrialized, demand for energy of all kinds increases. One fuel where America has an advantage is natural gas.

· Oct 23, 2024 · 3 min read

SEC building exterior representing climate disclosure regulations
Commentary

SEC's Climate Disclosure Rules: A Threat to Economic Growth and Energy Security

In March 2024, the SEC adopted climate disclosure rules requiring U.S. corporations to report their carbon footprint and climate-related risks.

Paul H. Tice · Sep 11, 2024 · 3 min read

Electric vehicle charging at a home charging station
Commentary

What would an all-EV future look like?

Eighteen states will require all new vehicles to be electric by 2035. NCEA counts the true cost, starting at $1,750 per home for charging alone.

Jonathan Lesser, PhD · Aug 07, 2024 · 5 min read